Image: Ontheroad, Lightstock.com

Ecumenical Lutherans – Learning from Chemnitz

One key characteristic of Christianity in America today is unrestrained fragmentation. There are over 250,000 churches in the U.S. today, divided into dozens of different church bodies. Nowadays the biggest groupings are Roman Catholic and non-denominational Protestants. It seems as if a new church group pops up every week.

How should orthodox Lutherans engage in God-pleasing ecumenism in this context of unrestrained fragmentation? The old early 20th century style of the liberal Protestant ecumenical movement is most certainly not the way to go, seeking the lowest common denominator approach, agreeing to disagree about important theological matters, ignoring the theological and doctrinal level and focusing more on social action, and compromising on fundamental theological positions. As Richard John Neuhaus once quipped, that approach asserts, “Here I stand, and here, and here.”

If that is one ditch to avoid, there is another ditch to be avoided as well, the ditch of isolationism. This is a temptation, “to take our ball and go home,” to simply debate internal and intramural questions with other Lutherans and ignore the bigger theological scene. That is not in the Reformation tradition.

We need to remind ourselves that this is not a Lutheran country, that 98% of Christians in America are non-Lutheran. Simply talking to ourselves does not help anybody and in fact does a disservice to our own cause. We need to remember that orthodox Lutheranism is simply orthodox Christianity that believes, teaches, and confesses the one true biblical Faith, focused on teaching the Scriptures in their truth and purity, the pure gospel as the central engine, the right teaching and practice of baptism and the Lord’s Supper and confession/absolution, and confessing the ancient ecumenical creeds. We are on the main highway of biblical catholic Christianity in continuity with the confession of the early church fathers. Our complaint is that other groups have diverged off the main highway of orthodox Christianity onto rabbit trails by introducing innovations that obscure and distort the gift of God and dangerously mislead people.

So what is our ecumenical task in our context of unrestrained fragmentation? Orthodox Lutherans do seek altar and pulpit fellowship with other orthodox Lutherans. This is very possible, and when it happens we rejoice. But maybe in our American context, with the institutional culture of its church bodies, our greatest opportunities lie elsewhere. It could be that the way to engage in God-pleasing ecumenism is more on the individual and/or local level, trying to have influence with individual pastors and teachers and lay persons who are non-Lutheran.

How can you participate in such God-pleasing ecumenism? I think there are more possibilities than people might realize. Maybe start your own talk radio show. Dr. Greg Seltz out east has his own talk radio show, “The Drive Home with Dr. Greg Seltz” on 105.1 FM, 4-6 pm. Create podcasts and YouTube videos. Start a neighborhood Bible class or start a clergy Bible class with non-Lutherans where you simply walk through a book of the Bible chapter-by-chapter. When theological and doctrinal disagreements come up, having a common biblical text on the table greatly facilitates such discussions. And Lutheran lay people need to be talking about matters of theology with non-Lutherans much more. I’m not talking about unionism but about finding ways to talk theology with non-Lutherans and trying to have some theological influence among non-Lutherans.

In the task of God-pleasing ecumenism what should you push for? You should push for moving toward the main highway of biblical catholic Christianity, for the “ones” of the biblical Faith: the one gospel (Galatians 1:6-9), the “ones” highlighted in Ephesians 4:3-6, namely, one body of Christ, one Holy Spirit, called to one hope, one Lord Jesus, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father, and the one Lord’s Supper (1 Corinthians 10-11). In this way you would be “diligent to preserve the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace” (Eph 4:3), seeking to avoid false teaching that causes dissensions (Romans 16:17) and to agree with no divisions (1 Corinthians 1:10).

 How should you argue and make your case? I have been rereading the magnum opus of Martin Chemnitz, Examination of the Council of Trent (translated by Fred Kramer and published by Concordia Publishing House). Martin Chemnitz was the Michael Jordan of Lutheran theologians, right up there with Martin Luther. How did he argue? First, he did not take cheap shots, caricaturing the other position and simply hurling grenades across the field. He did his homework and understood the positions and documents used in the Council of Trent. Second, he argued from the Scriptures in a very responsible way, and he constantly appealed to the early church fathers on every point of contention. While he made use of Martin Luther’s writings, those were not his only sources. Chemnitz’s entire argument was that our confessional Lutheran position is on the main highway of biblical catholic Christianity in conformity with the Scriptures and in line with the early church fathers. And we need to present our position this way, not as sectarian innovators, not as some society for the preservation of a 16th century church father, but as simply the biblical catholic position. And that was, in fact, the position of Martin Luther himself.

In short, “don’t take your ball and go home.” It is time to play offense with our orthodox theology. Mix it up theologically with non-Lutherans. Confess – winsomely and joyfully!  There is no reason to be defensive. Have confidence in the causative power of the Word of God.


Dr. Paul Raabe photo
Dr. Paul Raabe, Professor Emeritus of Exegetical Theology, Concordia Seminary, St. Louis

Posted

in

by

Comments

Leave a Reply